How do you actually defeat monsters in No Thank You, Evil?

November 21, 2026 3 answers
Asked by 3MbuttonMap

I'm new to the game and confused about combat. Does a monster's level tell you what to roll, and does its health mean you have to succeed that many times? I'm also unsure when to ask for rolls and use tokens.

Answers

DOSjoystickSqueak

Those are two separate things. The monster's level is used to determine how hard it is to affect, while its health tracks how much it can take before it's defeated. A level 3 monster with 3 health doesn't automatically mean you need three rolls of 3 or higher.

Check the combat and damage rules for the specific attack being used. A successful attack reduces health by the damage it deals, so the number of successes needed depends on that damage. I wouldn't treat level as the exact number to roll without checking the game's difficulty rules first.

3MbuttonMap:

So health is a running total, not a count of successful rolls. That helps.

Reply to this answer
DOSsoundCardPigeon

For actions outside combat, let the kids describe what they want to do first. Putting imaginary grip tires on a car can just happen if it's a fun detail. Crossing a dangerous bridge might call for a roll if the outcome is uncertain and failure would matter.

They don't have to pick the same action. One can inspect a device while the other crosses. Just take turns hearing what each wants to try and decide whether either action needs a roll.

Reply to this answer
GBAopcodeMuffler

I'd keep the tokens visible and check the rulebook when someone wants to use one. The question of whether they can only be spent to try harder is separate from how monster health works, so it's worth checking the token rules rather than guessing during a fight.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions