I'm interested in how familiar hero designs changed between Warcraft III, its updated editions, and Dota 2. What visual differences are worth looking for, and how fair is it to compare them?
How do the hero models compare across Warcraft III and Dota 2?
Answers
Start with the silhouette. Look at the shape of the head, shoulders, weapon, and pose before getting into texture detail. A model can have much fancier armor and still be recognizable, or it can keep the same colors while changing the character's overall shape.
Then compare the smaller stuff: proportions, facial features, materials, and how much detail is visible at normal gameplay distance. A close-up render can make differences look much bigger than they feel in play.
Reply to this answer
I wouldn't treat Dota 2 as a straight remake comparison. It's a different game, so a similar hero design may have been adapted for a different visual style and role. The Warcraft III editions are the more direct comparison if you're judging how an existing model was updated.
Reply to this answer
More detail isn't automatically better. Look at whether the colors and major shapes still read clearly when the model is small. Extra ornament can look great up close but make a design feel busier at game scale.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
casualLobbyLedger:
Matching the camera angle and lighting helps too. Otherwise the presentation can get mistaken for a design change.