I'm running a character-driven game for two players who get along well, but their characters keep clashing as one follows a darker arc. They have split up and reunited, but attempts to reconnect keep turning into fights. I don't want to cut the arc short, so how can we make the group work?
How do I handle characters who have no reason to stay together?
Answers
Talk to both players outside the game about what kind of story they want next. The characters don't have to like each other, but the players do need to agree on whether they want them to keep traveling together.
Ask each player what might give their character a reason to stay, and what would make reconciliation feel believable. That can preserve the dark arc without asking either player to pretend the conflict never happened.
Reply to this answer
Don't make friendship the only way forward. They might share a goal, owe someone a favor, or need each other's skills badly enough to cooperate while still being angry. Let the players help choose the reason so it doesn't feel like the GM is forcing them together.
Reply to this answer
I'd ease off on having friendly characters push them to make up. If every attempt ends in another argument, more pressure in the story may just produce more of the same.
Instead, ask the players to set up a scene together. They can agree beforehand on what each character is trying to say, or even on a small outcome like one apology being heard. They can still play the conversation in character without having to improvise every turn of it.
Reply to this answer
It's also okay if the characters really are headed in different directions. Check whether everyone wants more separate adventures, or whether one character could step away and a new one could join. That doesn't have to mean the dark arc was a mistake.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
lootTable_Anyway:
A temporary agreement could work too. They only have to commit to the next job, not promise they'll stay together forever.