I want a small-city campaign with hidden, costly magic, noir investigation, and characters who keep finding bigger questions than answers. Unknown Armies is my starting point, but I'm also curious which Mage: The Ascension books would be useful for street-level occult material rather than powerful mages and sprawling conspiracies. I already have Orphan's Survival Guide.
How do I build a Hellblazer-style occult campaign without going too big?
Answers
I'd start with Orphan's Survival Guide before buying more Mage books. Look for individual practices, occult subcultures, and conflicts you can lift without importing the whole setting. A useful idea might be a ritual, a strange belief, or a relationship between practitioners, not necessarily an entire faction.
Keep Unknown Armies in charge of the rules if that's the feel you want. Mage material can add texture, but you don't have to bring over its assumptions about how powerful or connected everyone is.
Reply to this answer
Make the cost of magic specific to the person using it. A working might require a broken promise, a favor owed to someone dangerous, or a sacrifice that makes the next investigation harder. The players should have some idea what they're risking before they choose.
Keep the effects small and unsettling. Getting a dead person's final memory could solve one problem while revealing that someone else knows the characters were looking.
Reply to this answer
For the noir side, build cases around people with conflicting needs rather than a single hidden villain. Someone wants a missing person found, someone wants them left alone, and both have reasons they aren't telling the whole truth.
Give the characters several ways to uncover the essential clues. Then let each answer point to a wider mess without making the original case feel pointless. They can find the missing person and still discover that helping them has a nasty price.
Reply to this answer
Being out of your depth works better when there are still choices that matter. Let the characters win a case, protect someone, or bargain their way out, even if they can't fix the whole city. Otherwise every revelation can start to feel like another dead end.
Reply to this answer
Before leaning into the grim stuff, talk about which themes the group wants on screen and which are off limits. Morally dubious choices don't have to mean graphic cruelty, and knowing the boundaries gives you more room to make the remaining choices uncomfortable.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
GBCmapper_5Q:
Costs can hit relationships as well as the caster. Just give the group room to decide which relationships they're willing to endanger.