How do diceless RPGs decide what happens?

November 15, 2026 4 answers
Asked by lagCompensator+Fig

I'm curious about games that don't use dice or other random draws. What do they use to resolve uncertain situations, and are there approaches beyond comparing stats or spending points?

Answers

quickloadSidegig

One straightforward method is to compare character abilities. If two characters compete, the higher relevant rating wins. That makes character strengths reliable, though the game still needs a way to handle ties and situations where more than one ability could matter.

Traits can work similarly without being just a numerical contest. Realis uses traits framed around what a character always does, with ranks helping resolve situations where an appropriate opposing trait comes into play.

Reply to this answer
walltech+Macaroni

Resource economies are another big option. Instead of rolling, you decide whether a situation is worth spending effort, luck, or another limited resource on. That shifts some of the tension from whether you get lucky to how much you want to commit now versus save for later.

Nobilis and Belonging Outside Belonging offer examples of games using resources in diceless play, though they don't necessarily use them in the same way.

LANcable.Whimsy:

That also means a player can have a meaningful choice even when the possible outcomes are predictable.

Reply to this answer
parryTaximeter

Some games put more weight on the actual approach than on a character sheet. Stalker has a procedure that scores the player's idea and roleplaying, multiplies those scores, and compares the result to a difficulty.

That's more structured than simply asking the game master to pick an outcome, but it still relies on their judgment. Whether that sounds fun or frustrating probably depends on how much discretion your group wants at the table.

Reply to this answer
hitstunAllowance

One useful distinction when looking for examples: diceless doesn't always mean randomless. A game can skip dice and still draw colored tokens from a bag to determine an outcome. If you want no random element at all, check the resolution procedure rather than just the label.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions