I keep seeing damage bonuses described as additive or multiplicative. How do the buckets affect the final number, and how should I compare bonuses on gear?
How do damage modifier buckets actually work?
Answers
Think of a bucket as a group of bonuses that get added together before the result is multiplied by other parts of the damage formula. So two bonuses of 20% and 30% in the same additive bucket give you a 1.5 multiplier, not 1.2 times 1.3.
If the 20% and 30% bonuses are instead separate multipliers, they give you 1.2 times 1.3, or 1.56. That's a 56% increase over the starting damage. The exact grouping depends on the game and sometimes the version, so the label alone isn't always enough to tell you where a bonus goes.
Reply to this answer
For gear comparisons, look at what you already have in the bucket. If your existing additive bonuses total 200%, that bucket is 3.0. Adding another 30% takes it to 3.3, which is a 10% increase in damage, not 30%.
By comparison, a separate 10% multiplier would also raise damage by 10%, assuming both bonuses apply to the same hits. That's why a smaller multiplicative bonus can compete with a much larger additive one.
Reply to this answer
Don't forget the starting damage. A skill's damage, weapon damage and relevant stats can feed into the calculation before the bonuses you're comparing. A bigger percentage bonus on an item doesn't automatically make it better if you're giving up something else that affects the base calculation.
Critical hits, vulnerable targets and damage over time can also have their own rules. Check whether a modifier applies to the kind of damage you're actually trying to improve.
Reply to this answer
One naming trap: a bonus called multiplicative isn't necessarily a separate multiplier from every other bonus. Some sources may be grouped together inside a bucket, then that bucket multiplies the rest of the formula.
For Diablo 4, the shorthand often uses [+] for additive and [x] for multiplicative bonuses. The exact bucket rules can change between seasons, so check the current version before relying on a detailed formula.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
_manaMinder+7:
And if a bonus only applies to certain hits or enemies, its value across a whole fight depends on how often that condition is active.