I saw an allegation that a popular Vintage Story mod contained hidden code that caused crashes when certain other mods were present. How much can players do to check whether a mod is trustworthy, especially when lots of other mods depend on it?
How can you tell if a game mod is safe to install?
Answers
Popularity and download counts aren't security checks. A widely used library mod can be a single point of failure because people may install it as a dependency without looking at it directly.
Check where the download comes from, whether the project has available source code, and whether the release has been independently reviewed. Source availability helps, but it doesn't prove the downloadable file matches the source or that anyone has examined the risky parts.
Reply to this answer
The reported behavior here is sneakier than a mod simply refusing to run alongside another one. The allegation is that code hidden in a library checked for other loaded assemblies and then caused delayed, intermittent failures while suppressing errors.
That distinction matters for troubleshooting. A crash that looks random might still be triggered by a particular combination of mods. A code review by someone who understands the game and its modding system would be more useful than judging from the symptom alone.
Reply to this answer
For ordinary players, keep backups of saves and avoid installing mods from random repackaged downloads. If a mod is under a credible security warning, remove or disable it and check which other mods depend on it before loading a valued save.
An antivirus scan is worth running if you're worried, but a clean result doesn't establish that a mod is harmless. Some unwanted behavior may look like ordinary game code to a scanner.
quickreloadByWhim:
Does removing the dependency mean the other mods will stop working?
P8parryCheck_7D:
They might. Check their dependency requirements and disable the affected mods too if they won't load without it.
Reply to this answer
There's also a trust question separate from the technical one. A mod author can disagree with how people play, but deliberately breaking a client in ways that are hard to trace is very different from clearly stating an incompatibility or declining to support another mod.
The specific claims still need to be evaluated on their evidence. If confirmed, a maintainer's role or reputation wouldn't make that behavior acceptable.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
rogueTraitPatch_9M:
Also check the dependency list when adding a mod. The small library it pulls in may have just as much access as the mod you wanted.