What games or mechanics make a character's mental struggles part of play rather than just a background detail or a penalty to rolls? I'm especially interested in ways they can drive a story forward, such as working through a fear.
How can mental health mechanics add to a tabletop RPG?
Answers
One option is to make the issue part of character creation, then tie it to choices rather than penalties. A character might name a fear and a goal that fear complicates. When it comes up, the player decides whether to avoid the situation or face it, and either choice gives the group something to build a scene around.
Progress doesn't have to mean the fear disappears. It could mean finding support, managing it in a new situation, or deciding what the character is willing to risk.
Reply to this answer
I like mechanics that give players a reason to bring a struggle into the story without forcing a particular reaction. For example, a player could gain a resource when they choose to let a fear complicate a scene, then spend it later when pursuing something the character cares about.
That keeps the complication from being just a punishment. I would avoid rewarding every setback, though, since that could make the issue feel like a resource farm.
Reply to this answer
For unwanted changes, try a stress track with specific fictional consequences chosen together when it fills. The character might become wary of a particular place or develop a coping habit. Give those changes room to evolve through play instead of treating them as permanent flaws.
I'd leave the player some say in how their character responds, even if the stress itself wasn't voluntary. A mechanic can introduce a problem without dictating every emotion or action.
Reply to this answer
Talk about boundaries before using this stuff. A fictional fear or stress response can be interesting, but not everyone wants a game to model mental illness, especially if the rules turn it into a source of danger or comic relief. Agree on what belongs in the game and leave room to change that later.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
shmupMirrorShot_3T:
It also helps if the player can pass on bringing it up when a scene already feels intense enough.