How can I help new Monsterhearts players take more initiative?

November 19, 2026 4 answers
Asked by P6!ManaWaypoint

My players are new to Monsterhearts and seem unsure what to do without me driving the scenes. Are there useful prompts or structures that can help them take initiative?

Answers

queue+Pancake

Give them a small, concrete choice instead of asking what they want to do in general. Try something like, “You see someone you care about leaving with your rival. Do you follow them, confront them, or do something else?” The options make it easier to start, but leave room for their own idea.

Once they choose, follow through on the consequences and hand the decision back. They do not need to come up with a whole plot, just one thing their character wants to do next.

Reply to this answer
manaOnTheMargins

Before a scene, ask each player for one thing their character wants from someone else and one thing they want to keep hidden. Those are handy handles when the table gets quiet.

You can also ask where they go to pursue that want and who they bring along. Let the answers set up the next scene rather than preparing every scene yourself.

lootTableByTeapot:

It may help to keep those wants short term at first. Getting an apology today is easier to act on than wanting to be popular someday.

Reply to this answer
coinopDaytripper

Check the characters' moves and relationships together. Ask what kinds of messy situations would give those abilities and connections something to work with, then put one of those situations in front of them.

Make clear that they can start conversations, seek people out, make plans and cause trouble without waiting for an invitation. New players may simply not know how much control they have.

Reply to this answer
stealthBuildSundays

Pause out of character and ask what would make it easier to act. Some players might want more information about the situation, while others might be worried about making a bad choice or putting another character on the spot.

For a practice scene, keep the stakes manageable and let them talk through possible actions as a group. You can gradually step back as they get more comfortable.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions