Grimwild or Legend in the Mist for a long campaign?

November 20, 2026 4 answers
Asked by P3dashFeint~Unplanned

I'm choosing between Grimwild Community Edition and Legend in the Mist for a heroic fantasy campaign that could run 30 or more sessions. What should I consider before buying and planning around one of them?

Answers

scrim3mapVeto

Start by checking how each game handles character advancement over a long campaign. Look at whether characters gain new abilities, change their existing ones, or retire and make room for new characters. Thirty sessions can feel very different depending on what kind of growth the rules support.

Also check how much preparation the game expects from the person running it. A system that sounds great for a short adventure may be harder to sustain if its prep style doesn't suit you.

Reply to this answer
CRTscanline+Stapler

I'd compare the kind of heroic fantasy each game is aiming for before worrying about campaign length. Do you want the group focused on dangerous adventures, personal stories, exploring a setting, or some mix of those? Check the descriptions and any available previews for both games against what your players actually want.

kartTrailLine+Pencil:

It may help to ask the group what they want their characters to be doing by session ten, not just what genre sounds appealing.

Reply to this answer
P6throwTech!Late

If you can sample the rules before buying, try a short scenario with each. Give both the same broad premise and see how the table likes character creation, resolving conflicts, and coming up with what happens next. A two-session test won't prove which game is best for thirty sessions, but it can expose a bad fit early.

Reply to this answer
scrimStandin_6R

For the purchase side, check exactly what comes with Grimwild Community Edition and what you'd need to buy for Legend in the Mist. Also look for campaign guidance, examples of play, and tools for creating adventures. The most useful book is the one that helps you run the game you have in mind.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions