Does gear progression need so much re-rolling?

November 19, 2026 4 answers
Asked by buttonRemap+Kettle

Random drops are part of the appeal for me, but having to repeatedly roll so many different parts of a build gets tedious. Would more deterministic crafting make gear progression better, or would it take away the excitement?

Answers

shmupBomb.6N

Some randomness is fine, but it gets exhausting when nearly every step asks for another roll. Tempering, enchanting, amulet aspects, unique powers and charms all compete for resources and attention.

Give players a reliable way to work toward at least some upgrades. A lucky roll could still save time, but a long streak of bad rolls shouldn't leave you feeling like you've made no progress.

buttonRemap+Kettle:

That's the part that bothers me. Getting the result feels more like relief than excitement after enough attempts.

Reply to this answer
deckSideboard+Rake

Enchanting is especially rough when you're chasing both the right affix and a good value. Costs can climb into the billions, and there's no guarantee the next roll will be any better.

I'd separate choosing the affix from improving its value, or give players a way to lock in progress. That would leave room for good and bad rolls without making the whole process feel like starting over every time.

Reply to this answer
questcrumb

The unique to mythic unique upgrade has a different problem. You can spend a rare material for a chance at the item you want and still get stats worse than the unique you're already using. That's a hard sell when the cost is scarce.

P1throwTech!Late:

A chance at a new item is one thing, but the possible downside makes it harder to feel good about spending the material.

Reply to this answer
ROMsector+Spanner

I'd keep some big random outcomes. Finding an unexpectedly strong item can be fun, and not every piece needs to be fully planned out. But wide unique power ranges and repeated charm rolls add a lot of clicking after the item has already dropped.

Maybe the drop can be the surprise, while refining the item is more predictable.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions