Super Mario Galaxy 2 reportedly moved from a 97 to a 98 aggregate score, putting it higher in the all-time rankings. How much does a change like that tell us about the game or its critical reputation?
Does a higher aggregate score really change Super Mario Galaxy 2's legacy?
Answers
Not much has changed about the game itself. A score moving by one point can change its position in a tightly packed ranking, but that doesn't necessarily mean critics have suddenly developed a different view of it.
I'd take the ranking as a snapshot of how the aggregate is calculated at a particular time, not as a definitive order of the best games ever made.
Reply to this answer
The useful question is what caused the score to change. An aggregate can shift when its underlying review data or calculation changes, and a rounded whole number can make a small difference look bigger than it is.
Without knowing the reason for this particular update, I wouldn't read too much into it. The individual reviews are still more useful if you want to know what critics liked or disliked.
Reply to this answer
Rankings can still be fun, though. Getting into the top few is a neat bit of recognition, even if nobody needs to pretend the difference between 97 and 98 settles which game is better.
Reply to this answer
Critical legacy is broader than a score. Reviews can tell you how a game was received, while later discussion can tell you whether people still find its ideas interesting. An aggregate is one piece of that picture, not the whole thing.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
RAMdiskDandelion:
That makes sense. The jump in ranking sounds more dramatic than a one-point change on its own.