The main levels sound easy to finish, but there seems to be more to the game after the first credits. Does its structure make it harder for reviews to capture what the game does well?
Do reviews miss what makes Yoshi and the Mysterious Book fun?
Answers
It may be a game that changes quite a bit depending on what you try to do. Reaching the end of a level is one thing. Going back for flowers can turn it into more of a puzzle platformer, where figuring out how to collect everything is the challenge.
That makes a simple description like “easy platformer” potentially misleading. Still, the first credits and basic levels are part of the game too, so a review can reasonably focus on how satisfying they are without assuming every player will chase collectibles.
Reply to this answer
The credits aren't necessarily a good stopping point for judging the whole thing. More content opens up afterward, and the later creature designs and levels may be a big part of the appeal. A review that covers how much there is beyond that first ending would be more useful than one that treats it as the finish line.
dpadDayworker:
That's the part I was wondering about. It sounds like the game keeps revealing more after what looks like a natural endpoint.
Reply to this answer
Maybe, but I wouldn't assume reviewers stopped at the first credits just because they gave it a lower score. Someone can see the later content and still find the early game too easy, or simply not enjoy hunting for every flower.
The useful thing to look for is what a review says about those activities, not just the number at the end. If it explains how much of the game it covers, even better.
Reply to this answer
If you like 2D collectathons, the structure sounds like a good fit. The goal isn't only to get through each stage. There's also the question of what you missed and how to reach it. If that sounds tedious rather than fun, the easy route through the levels might be what matters most to you.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
hitbox-heckler:
That distinction helps. Collecting can be the main attraction for one player and optional busywork for another.