Debuff immunity seems different from the old spell immunity system, where many spells could not affect an immune target at all. Do the newer interactions make traditional carries less viable, or is that putting too much weight on one mechanic?
Did the debuff immunity changes make carries harder to balance?
Answers
There is a real balance concern there. If a carry activates Black King Bar expecting a clean window to fight, but debuffs can still be applied and remain after immunity ends, that window is less reliable than it looks.
Maledict is a good example of why the distinction matters. A spell not piercing debuff immunity does not necessarily mean every part of its interaction is ignored. That makes it harder to judge when a carry can safely commit.
Reply to this answer
I would be careful about blaming the whole carry pool on this one change. A hero's damage, farm speed, matchups and item choices all affect whether it gets picked. An awkward immunity interaction can matter without proving why a particular hero is absent from a tournament.
Reply to this answer
The wording is the part that trips me up. If an effect is marked as not piercing debuff immunity, players might reasonably expect it to be blocked entirely. Instead, damage and debuff behavior can be separate questions.
Bloodthorn's damage interaction is the sort of thing that needs to be clear when deciding whether Black King Bar will save you. The extra magic resistance can reduce damage without making you immune to it.
Reply to this answer
There is a tradeoff though. Letting spells interact with an immune target gives the other side more to do than wait for immunity to expire. The issue is whether those interactions are predictable and whether carries have enough tools to deal with them.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
P11airThrow:
It also makes the timing more complicated. Avoiding the immediate effect and avoiding a debuff that outlasts immunity are two different things.