Daggerheart or Pathfinder 2e for our next campaign?

November 20, 2026 4 answers
Asked by ROMchecksum~Uncertain

I'm choosing between Daggerheart and Pathfinder 2e. I like character options and tactical combat, but I also want something manageable to learn and run. How do they compare for prep, combat, and a longer campaign?

Answers

coinopFlipper_5Q

Pathfinder 2e is the stronger pick if your group enjoys making tactical decisions and building characters from lots of options. Its rules give you a more structured framework, but that also means learning more terminology and checking how abilities interact.

You don't need to master every character option before starting. Focus on the basics and the choices your players actually bring to the table. There are also plenty of published adventures and resources if you don't want to build a campaign from scratch.

quickslot!WrongPocket:

Character creation can still take a while for a new group, especially if everyone wants to browse all the options first.

Reply to this answer
XPcrumbs!Pocketed

I'd lean Daggerheart if you want the story and character moments to lead the game. Hope and Fear give the results of rolls a different feel, and the smaller pool of material can make getting started less daunting.

The tradeoff is prep. If you have limited time and want a ready-to-run campaign, check what adventures are available before committing. A framework can help, but it isn't necessarily the same thing as a complete adventure.

Reply to this answer
parryAttempt+Bookmark

Try a short adventure in each before picking the long campaign. Character creation, a fight, and a scene outside combat should tell you more than comparing feature lists. Pay attention to what the players enjoy and how much work each game leaves you with as the person running it.

Reply to this answer
rankedQueue~LowStakes

Don't assume that simpler combat automatically means faster sessions, or that Pathfinder fights will always drag. Your group's familiarity and how much time people spend weighing choices will matter too. If tactical detail is the fun part, a longer fight might not feel like a downside.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions