Could this fictional 150,000-ton battleship actually work?

November 18, 2026 4 answers
Asked by deckMulliganOnBreak

I'm looking at a fictional Japanese battleship with an Amagi-inspired hull, some Yamato-style features, eight 48.3 cm guns and a planned speed of 30 knots. It is supposed to displace about 150,000 tons at standard load, with a 300 meter length, 38 meter beam and roughly 11 meter draft. Do those numbers fit together?

Answers

healbotOnBreak

The displacement is the first thing to check. A 300 by 38 by 11 meter rectangular box has a volume of 125,400 cubic meters. A ship's hull occupies less volume than that box, even before you account for the fact that standard displacement and the stated draft may refer to different loading conditions.

So 150,000 tons looks incompatible with those dimensions. Either the hull needs to get substantially larger or the displacement figure needs to come down. An Amagi-like hull shape won't resolve that basic volume problem.

deckMulliganOnBreak:

So the hull dimensions need fixing before the armor and machinery weights can really be assessed?

strafeLeft:

Yes. After that, a weight budget for the hull, armor, guns, machinery and fuel would help test whether the revised design makes sense.

Reply to this answer
quickcast_3M

The 350,000 shaft horsepower figure is a starting point, not proof of 30 knots. Speed depends on the final hull shape and displacement, as well as propellers and other details. Once the dimensions are corrected, the power estimate needs another look too.

There's also the question of where all that machinery goes. The armor and torpedo protection take up space, and a long, narrow hull has to fit the machinery and magazines without compromising the layout.

Reply to this answer
modSlotWanderer

I like the eight big guns as a fictional centerpiece. The tricky bit is everything attached to them: turrets, ammunition storage, handling equipment and fire control. The proposed 41 cm belt and 21 cm deck sound formidable, but their actual weight depends on how much of the ship they cover.

The secondary and anti-aircraft guns need room and useful firing arcs too. Add the stern hangar, catapults and crane, and the deck plan could get crowded fast. A side view and a rough internal layout would tell you more than another round of weapon upgrades.

raidQueueAtNoon:

The triple 10 cm mounts are described as new for this design, so their size and placement would also need to be worked out rather than assumed.

Reply to this answer
laggyByNature

It works better as an alternate-history concept than as a finished engineering design. Decide what you want to preserve first: the enormous displacement, the 30-knot speed, or the relatively compact hull. Changing one will likely mean revisiting the others.

The Amagi and Yamato influences can still give it a recognizable look. They don't have to mean the resulting ship inherits either one's proportions or performance.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions