Could play-by-post work when scheduling is a mess?

November 15, 2026 5 answers
Asked by P7!RecoilMinder

I'm considering play-by-post because getting everyone together is difficult. I'm looking at Pico and Stonetop, but I'm unsure how their fluid spotlight and quick, theater-of-the-mind combat would translate to asynchronous play.

What formats or house rules help keep things moving? Does the GM need to handle all the rolls?

Answers

CRTKeycapRepair

I'd start with a small group and agree on a posting rhythm before choosing house rules. Play-by-post gets around the need for everyone to be free at once, but it still needs regular attention. Decide what happens when someone misses a couple of days, including whether the GM can move their character along in a low-stakes way.

Run a short scene first rather than committing to a whole campaign. That should show you whether the pace works for the group.

Reply to this answer
arcadeKeyring

For fluid combat, try resolving a whole exchange at once instead of waiting for a strict turn order. Players post what they want to do and any useful fallback, then the GM describes how the actions and enemy responses fit together. Give everyone a chance to contribute before shifting the spotlight again.

For theater of the mind, keep a short description of where everyone is and what immediate threats are in play. Ask for clarification when positioning would change the outcome, but don't make every small movement a separate post.

joystickLaundress:

A fallback can be as simple as saying what your character does if the target moves out of reach. That saves a round of questions.

Reply to this answer
rollbackDovetail

No, the GM doesn't have to roll everything. Players can roll for their own actions using whatever method the group trusts and can see. The GM can still roll for hidden information or situations where stopping to ask for a roll would slow the scene down.

Agree on that division beforehand, and check how rolls are supposed to trigger in the game you're using. Changing who rolls is one thing. Changing when a roll happens can affect the feel of the rules.

Reply to this answer
airControlLanyard

Crunch isn't automatically a dealbreaker, but back-and-forth is the thing to watch. A choice that takes ten seconds at a table can take several posts if the GM needs to ask for a roll, get the result, and then ask what the player does next.

One option is to let a post include the intended action, the relevant roll, and a conditional response when the rules allow it. Keep a separate place for out-of-character questions so they don't interrupt the scene.

Reply to this answer
hotbar.Weatherfax

It may be worth trying a shorter live session too, if the group can manage one. Play-by-post solves a different problem from players not following through. If people can't spare regular time to write, the game can stall even without a shared appointment.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions