Could inactivity checks make Dota Arcade player counts more trustworthy?

November 21, 2026 4 answers
Asked by deckTokenTally_3G

Some monetized Arcade games may have their player counts inflated by idle bot accounts. Could inactivity checks help, and what would a platform-wide version need to handle?

Answers

GBCspriteAuction_8T

One approach is to close a lobby after 15 minutes with no input from anyone, and close a match after five minutes with no hero orders from anyone. Give a warning before the cutoff and reset the timer when someone acts.

That checks for an entirely inactive session rather than punishing one person who stepped away. A closed session could also be excluded from match statistics, so it doesn't look like a normal completed game.

mechLimbCalibration:

Those timers would need to fit the game mode. A lobby waiting for players and a match where people take turns might need different rules.

Reply to this answer
arcadePaddleSqueak

Inactivity detection would catch the laziest padding, not bots in general. An account that sends occasional commands could keep a session alive without playing in any meaningful way. It might still be useful as a first filter, but I wouldn't treat the remaining count as proof of genuine players.

Reply to this answer
roguePerkWhistle+Sumac

Repeated inactive closures could trigger a temporary restriction on that account in the affected mode. For example, three closures in 24 hours could lead to a 24-hour lockout.

That adds friction if accounts just start another idle session after being kicked. But the warning and clear explanation matter, because a restriction based on inactivity alone can also catch legitimate players.

Reply to this answer
casualTank

The count itself is part of the problem. Smaller games can depend heavily on that visible number, so inflated activity can make a mode look more popular than it really is. Better filtering would help comparisons, though a number alone still wouldn't tell you much about the quality of a game.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions