Unique items feel less interesting without distinctive passives, but class-specific passives and complicated damage effects can be hard to follow. Would broader effects like crushing blow, auras, or extra resource stacks offer better build choices?
Could generic unique item passives make builds more interesting without adding confusion?
Answers
Generic effects could be a good middle ground. An aura or an extra stack can change how several builds play without tying the item to one class or skill.
The effect needs to be visible and understandable, though. If it changes damage, the description should explain what triggers it and what it actually does.
Reply to this answer
I’d be careful with damage mechanics like crushing blow. They sound simple as a concept, but players still need to know how they work against different enemies and alongside other damage bonuses. Adding a familiar name doesn’t automatically make the system clear.
Reply to this answer
Extra maximum stacks sound more appealing to me than another hidden damage multiplier. They give you a reason to think about how you generate and spend a resource, rather than just checking whether the number on an item is bigger.
Reply to this answer
Generic doesn’t necessarily mean more variety. If an effect is strong for almost everyone, it could just become the obvious item to equip. The interesting part is whether it has a tradeoff or works particularly well with certain builds.
quickloadParka:
And it should be clear enough to compare that tradeoff with whatever you give up in the same item slot.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
CRTphosphorMoth:
That visibility is what I’m after. A distinctive effect is more fun when you can tell why it matters.