There are a lot of fish materials in the game, but only a very small set of recipes seem to use them. A few players were talking about how a seasoning system and more fish dishes could make that whole side of cooking feel more useful.
Could fish use more recipes and a seasoning system?
Answers
Yeah, that would make a lot of sense. Right now fish feels like one of those resources that exists, but barely gets a real cooking loop around it. More recipes would already help, and a seasoning mechanic could be a nice way to stretch the same ingredients into different food buffs without making them overpowered.
I think the best version would be simple stuff, like a few different fish meals for different needs. One for healing, one for a small stat boost, one that lasts a bit longer. That way the ingredient pool gets more use without turning cooking into a huge complicated system.
Reply to this answer
I’d rather see seasoning as a crafting layer than a full new subsystem. Something like salt, herbs, spices, or smoked variants that get added onto existing dishes would fit better than making every fish recipe from scratch.
That also helps if they want to keep balance under control. The base fish item can stay common, then seasoning gives you the choice to tune the meal a little. It makes kitchen crafting feel a bit more alive without needing huge buffs everywhere.
Reply to this answer
The bigger issue is probably variety, not power. If there are only one or two fish recipes, people will just ignore fish once they get a couple of easier food options that do the same job.
Adding recipes tied to different fish types would be the cleanest fix. Some could be plain utility food, some could lean into buffs for endurance or survival, and a few could just be low-effort meals for fast use. Seasoning could be the cherry on top, but the recipe list itself needs to grow first.
ZenGamepad:
That feels right. A seasoning system sounds neat, but it does not really matter if the base recipe pool stays tiny.
Reply to this answer
I like the idea, but I hope they would keep it pretty grounded. Fish recipes should probably be easy to make and use ingredients people already collect a lot of, otherwise it turns into another niche system that sounds good and gets ignored.
Small buffs, quick prep, lots of overlap with existing survival food, that would be enough. The point is making fish useful, not turning every meal into a min-max project.
Reply to this answer
This would be a nice quality of life change for sure. Fish already feels like it should belong in a cooking update, and seasoning is a good excuse to reuse the same materials in a smarter way.
If they ever add it, I hope they keep the recipes readable and not too fussy. Simple fish stew, smoked fish, spiced fillet, that kind of thing would go a long way.
ClutchMeter:
Yeah, that’s basically the idea. Just more reasons to bother collecting fish instead of letting them pile up unused.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
ArmorCue:
Exactly, even small additions would make the fish parts feel less like clutter and more like actual food progression.