I saw a comparison of public Discord server membership counts for tabletop RPGs. How useful is that as a measure of which games people are actually playing online?
Can Discord membership counts tell us which RPGs are popular?
Answers
It's a snapshot of server membership, not a player count. People can join more than one server, stick around after they stop playing, or join because they're curious without ever starting a game. Plenty of players won't join a server at all.
So the numbers can point you toward sizable communities, but I wouldn't treat the order as a definitive popularity ranking.
Reply to this answer
The server descriptions matter a lot here. Some focus on one game, while others cover several games, a publisher, or related content. A membership total for one of those broader communities can't be assigned neatly to a single RPG.
Pathfinder also appears in two separate communities in the comparison. Adding those totals wouldn't give you a clean player count either, since membership could overlap.
Reply to this answer
The October 2026 snapshot is still interesting on its own terms. The Dungeons & Dragons server had about 326,000 members, and the Lancer community had about 66,600. That's a big gap, though it doesn't tell us how many people were actively playing either game.
Mothership appeared at about 18,500. Those figures describe the servers checked at that point in time, not a complete census of every community for each game.
Reply to this answer
I would be careful about calling it a ranking of online play. The comparison uses public invite screen counts, so communities that aren't represented there won't show up. A game could have several smaller groups instead of one large server, too.
If you repeat the comparison later, keep the same selection criteria and record the date. Changes might be interesting, but they still wouldn't establish how many games are being played.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
buttonCombo!Oops:
That makes sense. It sounds more useful for finding communities than counting active players.