I have a tabletop RPG based on a strange, ambiguous setting, but the rules and sample adventure seem focused on combat. There isn't much guidance for creating scenarios that capture the source material. Can better structure and adventure support make a game like that work, or is it better to start with different rules?
Can better adventure support fix an RPG that doesn't fit its setting?
Answers
Figure out what the characters actually do in a typical session before rewriting anything. In a setting built around unsettling announcements and unanswered questions, maybe they respond to a local problem, investigate its effects, and decide who to help without necessarily explaining the mystery.
Then build a repeatable scenario structure around that. Start with an ordinary situation that has gone wrong, add a few people affected by it, and give the players a decision with consequences. Leave some details unexplained, but make the immediate problem concrete enough that they can act.
Reply to this answer
Adventure guidance can do a lot, but it won't change what the rules reward. If most character abilities are about fighting, players may reasonably expect fights to be a big part of the game.
Try a short session using the existing rules and a noncombat scenario. Notice which abilities get used, where you have to improvise, and whether conflict resolution supports the choices you want at the table. That should tell you more than redesigning the whole book upfront.
Reply to this answer
Honestly, if your changes throw out most of the game, using another system is a perfectly good option. Keep the setting and any character ideas you like, then pick rules that support investigation, social trouble, or whatever your group wants to play.
scrimBanlistByDoodle:
Worth checking with the interested player first. They might be excited about the setting rather than attached to the published rules.
Reply to this answer
You don't need a giant rewrite just to test the premise. Make a small set of prompts for odd events, affected locations, and people with conflicting priorities. Combine a few, then give the group a reason to get involved.
A sample adventure or two would also make the intended tone easier to use than a pile of tables alone. The key is showing how an unsettling premise becomes a playable situation, not just a weird description.
Reply to this answer
There's also the workload question. Writing scenarios and guidance can be fun, but it is still design work. If making the game playable feels like a chore, it's fine to set it aside rather than turn a gift into a big project.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
mechThrusterSqueal_2W:
That helps. I was worried that keeping things mysterious meant I couldn't give the players anything definite to work with.