Can Anti-Mage time Counterspell to block or reflect Malefice, or would a very precise activation suggest scripting? What should I look for in a replay?
Can Anti-Mage counterspell Enigma's Malefice on reaction?
Answers
One successful Counterspell isn't enough to call it a script. Anti-Mage can anticipate Malefice when Enigma moves into casting range, or activate defensively before the cast. From a replay, those can look a lot like a reaction.
Reply to this answer
Check several encounters rather than just the one dodge. Look at when Counterspell starts relative to Enigma's cast, whether Enigma was visible, and whether Anti-Mage had a reason to expect the spell. Repeated, unusually precise activations are more suspicious than a single good read, but they still need context.
Reply to this answer
A long account history or thousands of hours doesn't prove someone is playing clean, and it doesn't prove cheating either. Treat that separately from what the replay actually shows.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
kartGearRatioGuess:
Normal speed can hide the timing too. Slowing the replay down may make it easier to see the sequence, even if it doesn't establish intent.