I've seen a claim that a solo dungeon boss has more resistance than the monster resistance cap. Would that make penetration and Breach ineffective until enough resistance has been removed?
Can a boss's resistance cap make penetration do nothing?
Answers
That's what would happen if penetration and resistance reductions are applied to the boss's uncapped resistance before the cap is enforced. Using the reported numbers, 36,400 resistance capped at 25,000 leaves 11,400 above the cap. Reducing it by less than that would still leave it at the capped value.
Once the reduction goes beyond 11,400, the effective resistance would start dropping below 25,000. That's a big catch, though: the calculation depends on the order the game applies the cap and reductions. The reported damage test is consistent with that order, but it doesn't prove the exact resistance values by itself.
Reply to this answer
I'd test it with the same attack and conditions each time, first with no penetration or Breach, then with each reduction separately and combined. Compare enough hits to account for critical strikes and other damage variation. If the damage only rises after the combined reduction passes a threshold, that would be stronger evidence of the cap behavior.
Reply to this answer
If the report holds up, it makes gearing for that encounter pretty awkward. A smaller investment in penetration could give no damage benefit at all, while a larger one might work. I wouldn't assume that applies to other bosses without checking their resistance and cap too.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
P5safeJump!Eventually:
So penetration isn't necessarily useless for the whole fight, but it could have a dead zone before it starts helping?