Blades in the Dark or Reign 2E for faction play?

November 20, 2026 3 answers
Asked by raidBuffOnBorrow

I'm planning a drop-in campaign with a large group using Daggerheart. I want the characters to affect factions and the wider world without adding too much GM bookkeeping.

Would Blades in the Dark or Reign 2E be a better fit for handling faction interactions in a custom setting?

Answers

LANguest+Notebook

I'd start with Blades if keeping the campaign moving is the priority. Its faction setup looks like the lighter option, which could suit a rotating group where not everyone needs to follow every development.

The tradeoff is that a simpler approach may leave more of the faction decisions and outcomes to your judgment. If you want more structured group-level play, Reign's Company rules sound closer to what you're after.

Reply to this answer
deckTutor+Chopstick

Reign 2E is the one I'd investigate if the groups themselves are meant to be a major part of play, rather than just background pressures. The Company section is worth looking at as a possible add-on, but check how much of its structure you actually want to bring into Daggerheart.

More detail can give faction actions a clearer framework, but it also means more to track across sessions. For a drop-in game, I'd be selective about which groups get that level of attention.

quickslotMarmalade_5T:

That distinction helps. A few active groups with the rest handled more loosely sounds easier to manage than tracking every faction in detail.

Reply to this answer
shmupTapDodge_7W

You might not need to choose based on which system has the better faction rules in isolation. Think about what you want players to decide: are they mostly dealing with groups during adventures, or directing a group of their own between sessions?

For the first, a lighter setup may be enough. For the second, a dedicated Company framework could give those decisions more weight. Either way, keep a short record of what changed after each session so returning players can catch up.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions