Are there tabletop RPGs with systems like Darkest Dungeon?

November 18, 2026 4 answers
Asked by P4!CancelCheck

I'm looking for a tabletop RPG that captures some of Darkest Dungeon's mechanics. Are there games with stress or sanity, position-based combat, dungeon supplies, downtime, and traits that change through play?

A close match would be great, but suggestions that handle just a few of those things well are welcome too.

Answers

MUDscrollKeeper

I'd start by deciding which parts need to be actual rules and which can just shape the tone. Stress, formation, and limited combat moves are different design problems, so a game can feel grim and dangerous without covering all three.

When checking a system, look for how it handles characters changing between expeditions too. Downtime and lasting traits can do a lot of work in making each trip feel connected to the next.

Reply to this answer
framePerfect-ish

For the dungeon survival side, look for a game where supplies and resting affect decisions rather than just sitting on a character sheet. If food, light, and recovery matter, pushing deeper becomes a gamble even before the next fight starts.

Reply to this answer
quickSwap!Cabbage

Position-based combat is the part I'd check carefully before committing to a system. A grid alone isn't necessarily the same thing as a party formation where your rank controls which moves you can use and which enemies you can reach.

If you find a game you like otherwise, that might be the piece to adapt rather than trying to reproduce every video game mechanic at once.

Reply to this answer
midbossMischief

Stress is worth separating from ordinary damage. For the same kind of pressure, look for consequences that change how a character acts or what they're capable of, not just another pool of points to refill after a fight.

Positive traits matter too. If every lasting change is a punishment, the campaign might feel harsher than you're aiming for.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions