Are there PbtA games with more structured combat?

November 19, 2026 3 answers
Asked by aggroLedger.5V

I'm interested in Powered by the Apocalypse games, including Root, but I prefer fights that play out action by action rather than being wrapped up in a single roll. Are there games in that family with rounds or a bit more combat crunch, perhaps closer to D&D?

Answers

manaCurve_Quiet

A fight in a PbtA game doesn't necessarily end with one roll. A move might resolve one exchange, then the situation changes and the characters decide what to do next. That can mean several rolls over a fight, even without formal rounds or initiative.

The scope of a roll depends on the game and the situation. If you want everyone to get a predictable turn each round, though, multiple exchanges alone may not scratch that itch.

Reply to this answer
VODminder

I'd separate two things in your search: round structure and tactical crunch. A game could have a turn order but fairly simple choices, or have detailed combat moves without a D&D-style round. Think about whether your group most wants predictable turns, positioning, character abilities, or just fights that take more than one roll.

Reply to this answer
QCFbuffer_2T

Since Root already caught your eye, check its combat rules and examples before ruling it out. Look at how an exchange is triggered, what a roll resolves, and how the next action follows from the result. That should give you a better sense of the pace than the general PbtA label will.

aggroLedger.5V:

That helps. The distinction between several exchanges and a formal round is what I was trying to get at.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions