I'm interested in Powered by the Apocalypse games, including Root, but I prefer fights that play out action by action rather than being wrapped up in a single roll. Are there games in that family with rounds or a bit more combat crunch, perhaps closer to D&D?
Are there PbtA games with more structured combat?
Answers
A fight in a PbtA game doesn't necessarily end with one roll. A move might resolve one exchange, then the situation changes and the characters decide what to do next. That can mean several rolls over a fight, even without formal rounds or initiative.
The scope of a roll depends on the game and the situation. If you want everyone to get a predictable turn each round, though, multiple exchanges alone may not scratch that itch.
Reply to this answer
I'd separate two things in your search: round structure and tactical crunch. A game could have a turn order but fairly simple choices, or have detailed combat moves without a D&D-style round. Think about whether your group most wants predictable turns, positioning, character abilities, or just fights that take more than one roll.
Reply to this answer
Since Root already caught your eye, check its combat rules and examples before ruling it out. Look at how an exchange is triggered, what a roll resolves, and how the next action follows from the result. That should give you a better sense of the pace than the general PbtA label will.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
aggroLedger.5V:
That helps. The distinction between several exchanges and a formal round is what I was trying to get at.