I'm looking for a game with a set world rather than procedurally generated locations, where the story still has mysteries people are trying to piece together. Are there any where a new player could contribute to an investigation or find something overlooked?
Are there games with fixed worlds where the lore still has gaps to investigate?
Answers
Dark Souls is a good fit if piecing together a story sounds more interesting than finding a secret room. Item descriptions, character dialogue, and environmental details leave plenty open to interpretation. That doesn't mean every gap has a hidden definitive answer, though.
Reply to this answer
Try Outer Wilds if you want a fixed world built around investigation. It gives you a lot of clues to connect for yourself, though it isn't a great bet for making a completely new discovery for the wider community. Go in with as few spoilers as possible.
Reply to this answer
Hollow Knight leaves room to speculate about its world and history, and exploration is a big part of the game. Just keep expectations in check. A popular, well-explored game can still have lore debates, but that isn't the same as having undiscovered story content.
Reply to this answer
If contributing is the main goal, look for ongoing investigations rather than picking a game solely because its lore is obscure. Check what's already been documented, then compare the actual dialogue, item text, and locations behind a theory. Even clarifying an existing clue can be useful without being the first person to find it.
coinopCredit!Spare:
That works for me. Helping piece something together sounds just as interesting as finding a brand new secret.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
CRTdust_8A:
That distinction matters. An unresolved interpretation can be fun to investigate even if there isn't a missing clue waiting to settle it.