The DK and Werewolf reworks seem like visual and audio improvements, especially for Werewolf. But are they better to play, or are the skills just doing more things at once?
Are the DK and Werewolf reworks actually better to play?
Answers
More effects on a tooltip aren't automatically bad. A skill that combines related effects can free up space on your bar and make a build less fiddly. The question is whether those effects give you a meaningful choice or just make the button stronger.
Reply to this answer
I would separate presentation from gameplay. Better animations and sound can make a skill feel more satisfying, but they don't necessarily change the decisions you make during a fight.
For the gameplay side, look at whether the reworks change which skills you choose, when you use them, and how you respond to different situations. If the routine is basically the same, longer tooltips alone aren't much of a rework.
Reply to this answer
It might be worth judging DK and Werewolf separately rather than treating them as one package. The question points to a noticeable presentation improvement for Werewolf, but that doesn't tell us whether either rework plays better. More detail about the changed skills would help make that call.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
P9!DashAllowance:
Clarity matters too. A useful combined skill can still be hard to understand if the tooltip buries what the button is mainly for.