I've heard that roll-under games can work together with surprisingly little conversion. Does using your own character's stats for rolls make cross-system play easier, or are there bigger catches?
Are roll-under RPG systems easier to mix and adapt?
Answers
It can make the initial roll easier to translate. If an attacker rolls against their own skill and the defender rolls against their own dodge, neither character necessarily needs a stat from the other game just to make those checks.
That doesn't make the systems automatically compatible, though. You still need to decide what happens when both succeed, whether one result cancels the other, and how damage and defenses interact. Roll-under gives you a convenient starting point, not a complete conversion.
Reply to this answer
Watch the dice curves. A 13 or less on 3d6 succeeds about 84 percent of the time, while a 13 percent skill on d100 succeeds 13 percent of the time. The numbers on the character sheets aren't directly comparable, even though both games say to roll under.
I'd compare actual success chances and typical modifiers before deciding whether characters from different games belong in the same party.
Reply to this answer
Combat is where I'd expect the rough edges. One game might give a character more ability to take damage, another might subtract toughness or armor from every hit, and their weapons may use different damage scales. Keeping the attack rolls intact doesn't solve any of that.
Pick a common way to handle damage and defenses, then check a few typical fights before committing to a longer game.
Reply to this answer
It also depends what you're adapting. Mixing player characters from different games is a bigger job than borrowing a scenario and giving its opponents stats in the game you're already running.
Special abilities, magic, fear rules, and critical hits can have very different effects. A shared roll direction won't tell you whether those features are comparable or fit the tone you want.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
deckScryingGlass:
So the rolls can stay separate, but the way their results meet needs a ruling?
GBAwaitState_7N:
Exactly. Even deciding whether the defender gets a roll at all can depend on which game's rules you're using for the encounter.