Several recent games have felt heavily one-sided, with new accounts on both teams, even though Dota Plus showed a perfect match rating. Does that rating actually say anything about how balanced the game will be?
Are new accounts making Dota matchmaking feel uneven?
Answers
A perfect match rating isn't a guarantee of a close game. A match can look good on the information available before it starts and still end up lopsided once players pick heroes and start playing.
New accounts can be especially hard to place because there's less match history to go on. That doesn't mean every new account is a smurf, though.
Reply to this answer
The scoreboard alone doesn't tell you whether matchmaking got it wrong. A team can rack up kills after getting ahead, even if the players were reasonably matched at the start. A few rough games are frustrating, but they don't establish a wider spike in smurfs.
Reply to this answer
A minimum games played filter sounds nice until you consider what it does to genuinely new players. They still need matches too, and splitting the queue could make finding games harder. Better detection and quicker placement for experienced players on new accounts would be a more targeted fix.
Reply to this answer
If the games are consistently miserable, taking a break makes sense. The perfect match label doesn't make a bad game any more fun, and there's no reason to force another queue when you're already annoyed.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
DOSjoystickPacer_8E:
Even then, telling a fast learner from an experienced player on a new account can't be straightforward.