I want to spend Undaunted keys on shoulder pieces I haven't collected yet. Is the mystery coffer usually better value than choosing a specific set?
Are mystery Undaunted coffers better than picking a set?
Answers
For filling your collection, the mystery coffer is the better expected value from Glirion and Maj al-Ragath. Each has six sets, with six shoulder pieces per set. A set-specific coffer costs eight times as much as a mystery pull, but it still gives you a random one of the six pieces in that set.
That comparison is about the expected number of new pieces, not a guarantee that eight mystery pulls will all be useful. Duplicates can still happen.
Reply to this answer
Urgarlag is the exception worth checking. The mystery pool has 102 pieces across 17 sets, so a set-specific coffer can pull ahead if a large share of your missing pieces is concentrated in that one set. As a rough guide, look at the targeted option when that set contains more than about half of everything you still need from that vendor.
Reply to this answer
The gap gets less surprising if you think about a single specific piece. A set-specific coffer has a one-in-six chance of giving it to you. The mystery pool is bigger, but you get eight pulls for the same key cost.
For Glirion or Maj, the chance of getting that piece at least once in eight mystery pulls is about 20 percent, compared with about 17 percent from the set-specific coffer. That's assuming each piece in the pool is equally likely.
Reply to this answer
Planning to collect everything? Mystery pulls can still take a while because duplicates pile up near the end. Under the equal-odds model, the average is roughly 150 keys to clear either Glirion or Maj, and about 531 for Urgarlag. Those are averages, not budgets you can count on hitting exactly.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
stealthPatchwork:
That threshold is for expected new collection pieces. If you're chasing one particular shoulder, the chance of getting that piece may matter more to you than the total number of new pieces.