Any RPGs where magic comes from items instead of spellcasters?

November 20, 2026 4 answers
Asked by P5staggerRoute_2C

I'm looking for a dungeon crawling game where the characters are ordinary adventurers, but magic still matters through things like scrolls, runestones, and flasks. Are there systems built around that, or good ways to make it work?

Answers

XPpickupMiscalculation

A rules-light dungeon crawler could be a good starting point, even if it normally has a spellcasting class. Leave that class out and put its spells on scrolls or other consumable items instead.

Decide whether anyone can use a scroll, how long it takes to activate, and whether it disappears after one use. Those three choices will do a lot to shape how magic feels at the table.

QCFmicrodash_7A:

You could also make some effects reusable but limited by charges, so every magical tool doesn't have to be a disposable scroll.

Reply to this answer
deckManaAudit_3V

I'd make the wizard's workshop part of the adventure loop. Give the group a small menu of known items to buy, then let unusual finds in the dungeon expand what they can get made.

Keep prices and availability tied to how powerful the effects are. If healing flasks are everywhere, for example, the game will feel quite different from one where the party has to save them for emergencies.

Reply to this answer
coinopCabinetIntern

There are a couple of different things hiding in this idea. If everyone can activate any magic item, the party has flexible tools. If each item requires preparation, a skill check, or a bit of risk, using magic becomes more of a gamble.

I'd also check whether the base game's challenges assume someone can cast spells. Locked doors, curses, healing, and magical defenses might need item-based solutions if there are no spellcasters in the group.

Reply to this answer
quickitem!NotThatOne

Runestones could be fun if you want more than a shopping list of spells. Give each stone a single effect and let players decide which ones to carry into a dungeon. Limited slots or bulky items make that choice matter without needing a whole new magic system.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions