I'm looking for something with customizable armor, provisions and a workable economy. Injuries should matter and take time to heal. Low-powered magic is fine, but I don't want the game to depend on magical healing. Any systems worth a look?
Any grounded early medieval tabletop RPGs with survival and lasting injuries?
Answers
Mythras is worth checking if detailed combat is the main draw. It uses hit locations, armor on individual locations and injuries that can leave a character in serious trouble. That gives you room to distinguish a helmet and mail from a later suit of plate.
It isn't an early medieval history game out of the box, and the core rules include several kinds of magic. You can choose what to allow, but check the provisions and economy rules against what you want before committing.
Reply to this answer
For an explicitly early medieval setting, take a look at Wolves of God. It's set in early medieval England and has magic, but the historical setting is a much closer starting point than a generic fantasy world.
I wouldn't assume it has the detailed armor and maintenance rules you're after, though. Check those parts of the rules first if the equipment side is a must.
Reply to this answer
HarnMaster could fit the gritty end of the request. It has detailed armor, location-based injuries and a reputation for slow, dangerous healing. Harn is a fictional setting rather than early medieval Europe, so you'd still need to adapt the historical flavor and equipment.
Reply to this answer
For the provisions and travel side, consider Burning Wheel. Resources and survival can matter a lot, and injuries can have lasting consequences. It's not a dedicated early medieval game, though, and its rules have a particular focus on characters' beliefs and conflicts. Have a look at that style before choosing it just for the gear.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
_hitboxMarmalade:
That sounds like a good fit for injuries, at least. The fictional setting might be less of an issue if the rules support the tone.