Any fairly simple games with opposed attack and defense rolls?

November 16, 2026 4 answers
Asked by GBCcartographer

I'm looking for games where the attacker and defender roll against each other to resolve combat. Genre doesn't matter. What systems are worth checking out, and how do the rolls affect play?

Answers

casualCarrycase

Dragonbane is worth a look. The attacker rolls against a skill, and the defender can choose to dodge or parry. Those are separate rolls rather than simply comparing two totals, but they still give both sides an active part in the exchange.

The catch is that a dodge or parry uses the defender's action for the round. That makes defending a meaningful choice instead of a free roll every time someone swings at you.

Reply to this answer
QCF~PencilCase

Take a look at the Basic Roleplaying family, including RuneQuest. Attack and defense are skill rolls, with the outcome depending on how well each side succeeds. RuneQuest has more detail than a bare bones system, though, so it may be better as a reference for the mechanic than as the simplest option.

Reply to this answer
deckTech+Mittens

Burning Wheel uses opposed tests in some combat situations. Its Fight rules are much more involved, so I'd look at the simpler combat options first if what you want is a quick comparison of attack and defense mechanics.

Reply to this answer
critChanceSidecar

Fate is another option. An attack roll is opposed by a defense roll, and the difference between the results helps determine the effect. It's pretty quick once you know the dice and skills, although aspects and spending fate points add decisions around the roll.

airbrake-Jukebox:

That comparison of totals is a useful distinction. Some games have both players roll but judge the results against skill targets instead.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions