Which Nintendo Games Do You Think Are Overrated?

-

I’ve been contemplating how some Nintendo games I purchased didn’t live up to the hype. A prime example for me is Zelda: Spirit Tracks, which was super hyped but I found kind of disappointing. I’m curious, what Nintendo games do you believe are overrated?

Which Nintendo Games Do You Think Are Overrated
Cats the Commander for Nintendo Switch

Game guides, questions & answers and other Cats the Commander for Nintendo Switch posts. If the answer below was not helpful, and still need Help? Submit a comment below or ask a new question.

4 Answers

MarioFanX -

For me, Pokémon has never really caught my interest. I mean, everyone seems to go wild for it, but I’d be lying if I said it’s a game I enjoy. I just find it overrated because of the following it has.

RetroPlayer88 -

I totally agree! I feel like I’m just too old to get why it’s so loved. It’s like, yay for you all, but can we chill on the hype?

AnimalCrossingDude -

I’d put Animal Crossing: New Horizons on my list. I wish I hadn’t bought it! It’s fun, but the older games in the series hit differently for me because it felt more like life simulation rather than city building.

BuilderBoi -

Same! I love the older versions much more. New Horizons is cool but misses that neighborhood charm.

CriticOfGames -

Honestly, asking which games are overrated can be tricky since it’s all subjective. One person’s overrated gem can be another’s favorite, you know? Just because a game didn’t work for one person doesn’t take away its greatness for the majority.

ZeldaExpert99 -

I think Ocarina of Time is a classic, but it’s not *the* flawless masterpiece everyone claims it is. It’s good, for sure, but definitely overrated in my eyes.

TimeTraveler007 -

How dare you! It’s like, the holy grail of gaming!

Leave A Reply

CATS THE COMMANDER FOR NINTENDO SWITCH QUESTIONS

Is the recent Nintendo Switch update an April Fools' joke?
[Cats the Commander for Nintendo Switch] - Can kids play the new Nintendo Switch update on April Fools? A tired mom seeks help from the Reddit community. View Answer
Chill but Engaging Switch Games for a Week's Escape?
[Cats the Commander for Nintendo Switch] - What are some relaxing Switch games around 20-30 hours for escapism without being mindless? View Answer
Why Is Nintendo Removing Gold Points?
[Cats the Commander for Nintendo Switch] - Why is Nintendo removing gold points? I enjoyed them as rewards for purchasing games online! View Answer
Can the Switch Really Top the PlayStation 2 in Sales?
[Cats the Commander for Nintendo Switch] - Can the Nintendo Switch surpass the PlayStation 2 in sales with the upcoming Switch 2 release? View Answer
Best Ways to Play Classic Nintendo Games on Modern TVs Without Being a Tech Genius
[Cats the Commander for Nintendo Switch] - What are simple ways to play old Nintendo games on HD TVs without needing advanced tech skills? View Answer
Should the Switch eShop Have a Developer Block Button?
[Cats the Commander for Nintendo Switch] - Would a block button for developers on the Eshop improve user experience and visibility for quality games? View Answer

RELATED QUESTIONS

What if Hyrule and the Mushroom Kingdom Crossed Over?
[Super Mario: Battle for the Mushroom Kingdom] - What if Hyrule and the Mushroom Kingdom existed in the same universe? A crossover of epic proportions! View Answer
Looking for Nintendo-Inspired Names for My Baby Boy!
[The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom - Nintendo Switch 2 Edition] - Looking for Nintendo-inspired names for a baby boy? Discover unique options from iconic games like Zelda and Pokemon! View Answer
Will Zelda's Coronation and Her Wedding with Link Be One Ceremony or Two?
[The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - Nintendo Switch 2 Edition] - Will Zelda's coronation and her wedding to Link be one ceremony or two separate events in the 'Wild' saga? View Answer
What Are the Best ROM Hacks with the Longest Playtime?
What ROM hacks offer the longest playtime? Discover high-quality options for endless hours of gaming. View Answer
Is Cadence of Hyrule Worth the Price?
Is Zelda: Cadence of Hyrule worth buying for €17.50 if I'm broke and saving for the Switch 2? Need opinions! View Answer
Is Mario Kart World’s New Free Roam Mode the Future of Racing Games?
[Mario Kart World] - Is Mario Kart World's new Free Roam mode the open-world twist we've been waiting for in racing games? View Answer
What's the Best Way to Introduce My Kid to Pokémon Games?
[Pokémon] - Looking for advice on introducing my child to Pokémon video games and which might suit him best? View Answer
Who else here enjoys using Shuckle in their team?
[Pokémon] - Who loves using Shuckle on their team for its defense and strategies in Pokémon battles? View Answer
What's Your All-Time Favorite Pokémon?
[Pokémon] - What's your favorite Pokémon? Explore various beloved Pokémon from different fans in this engaging discussion. View Answer
Did Cave Story Ever Have a Strong Fandom?
[Cave Story] - Did Cave Story have a lasting fandom, or has it faded over the years despite its early influence in indie gaming? View Answer
What is Gigantamax in Pokémon?
[Pokémon] - What is Gigantamax in Pokémon and how does it work? View Answer
Will Super Mario Maker 3 Include Styles from NSMBU and Super Mario Bros Wonder?
Would a Super Mario Maker 3 feature separate styles for NSMBU and Super Mario Bros Wonder? I share my thoughts! View Answer