Struggling with the Reaper Rivals Commendation Grind?

-

Hey everyone! My friend and I have been trying to complete the Reaper Rivals commendation, and it’s been really tough finding other players to steal from. We’ve spent hours diving around looking for someone to take from, and most of the time we don’t come across anyone at all. So far, we’ve only managed to snatch about 4 skulls. It just seems so random if other players are even doing the voyage. Are we just having terrible luck, or is anyone else feeling the same pain? Any tips besides diving endlessly?

Struggling with the Reaper Rivals Commendation Grind
Sea of Thieves

Game guides, questions & answers and other Sea of Thieves posts. If the answer below was not helpful, and still need Help? Submit a comment below or ask a new question.

5 Answers

SkullThief2000 -

I think it’s mostly the casual players avoiding PvP that keeps the voyages from happening. My crew tried out the new missions a couple of times and got sunk each time. It totally killed our motivation to continue.

DerrickTheDiver -

If you want to be sneaky about it, why not try sweet-talking another crew while they’re doing their voyage? I’ve managed to get a couple of my steals that way without too much hassle. It’s not as fun as stealing outright, but it gets the job done faster if you’re just after the task.

TreasureSeeker99 -

Haha, that could work! But there’s always the risk they’ll try to pull a fast one on you!

SloopScallywag09 -

True, that gamble is real. But it’s worth a shot if you just want to get it done.

SloopScallywag09 -

I totally get what you’re saying. It’s the worst when you finally spot someone doing the voyage, and it’s a full galleon and you’re just rolling solo on a sloop. And yeah, the grind for 50 skulls feels way too long! I had a similar experience where I interrupted a guy’s event and dug up six reaper chests that he buried because of me, but it didn’t count as a steal since they were buried. Such a bummer!

TreasureHunterX -

Exactly! It’s wild that digging up treasure doesn’t count as stealing when technically, you are. They should reward that too!

LootLooter1 -

Right! Rare really needs to fix that system so that buried treasure is recognized as stolen if you dig it up.

CaptainStabby12 -

Honestly, I feel like the whole commendation thing is a mess. If no one’s really doing the voyage because everyone is too busy trying to snipe the loot, I guess it’s just going to stay dead until the community moves on from it. I personally avoid that mission until it’s old content to prevent getting sunk all the time.

DivingDuke -

That makes sense. It’s frustrating that Rare encourages this cat-and-mouse game. Even if you find a crew doing the voyage, you become such an easy target.

SkullyPirate88 -

I feel you on that! The game’s design does make it hard for players to enjoy the voyages when they know they’re instantly hunted.

SharkbaitDave -

It’s super annoying they locked cosmetics behind such a grind. Completing a voyage is already a challenge, and then to require so many skulls is just absurd! The whole thing feels out of balance after this season.

LootWorthy112 -

Totally! I wish more people would actually just embrace doing the voyages rather than camping to steal.

PvpPro22 -

I know right? The excitement dies down real quick when you’re just dealing with the same old problems. It’s like they want us to suffer instead of reward us for the grind.

Leave A Reply

SEA OF THIEVES QUESTIONS

Why is my 5080 struggling to hit 60 FPS in some games?
[Sea of Thieves] - Experiencing low FPS with a 5080 Aorus Master? Let's explore potential causes and solutions. View Answer
How to Level Up Gold Hoarders and Make Good Money in Sea of Thieves?
[Sea of Thieves] - How can I level up Gold Hoarders efficiently while making money in Sea of Thieves? View Answer
Can Skeletons See Your Lanterns in Sea of Thieves?
[Sea of Thieves] - Do skeletons see your ship's lanterns, or do they only spawn based on proximity? Here's what players think. View Answer
Is the Siren Skull Quest Really the Best Way to Earn Gold?
[Sea of Thieves] - Why stick to the repetitive Siren Skull quest when other profitable adventures await in the game? View Answer
How Can I Catch Rare Fish Instead of Just Splashtails?
[Sea of Thieves] - Expert fishermen, share your secrets for avoiding ruby splashtails and finding harder-to-catch fish! View Answer
What’s the Deal with Sea of Thieves 2024 vs 2025 Editions?
[Sea of Thieves] - What sets the 2024 and 2025 editions of Sea of Thieves apart? Is it worth buying 2025 with my progress intact? View Answer

RELATED QUESTIONS

Which JRPGs Have You Recently Dropped or Shelved?
[Fantasian Neo Dimension] - What JRPGs have you recently shelved or dropped, and what led to your decision? Let's share our gaming experiences! View Answer
Will Elden Ring be available on the PC Xbox App?
[Elden Ring] - Will Elden Ring be available on the PC Xbox App? Currently, it's not listed. View Answer
Is the Highway a Loop or Just a Straight Line?
[Death Stranding 2: On The Beach] - Is the highway network a loop or a straight line in the game? Discover the layout through discussions in the community. View Answer
What's the Most Ridiculous Moment in Resident Evil?
What are the most ridiculous moments from the Resident Evil series that make us laugh and shake our heads in disbelief? View Answer
How Can I Be a Versatile Player Without Sacrificing My Character Style?
[The Elder Scrolls Online] - Seeking tips on balancing character abilities in gaming without sacrificing play style or performance. View Answer
What are Some Irremovable Status Ailments in JRPGs?
[Final Fantasy] - What status ailments in JRPGs can't be cured by regular methods? Explore some unique examples in this discussion. View Answer
Understanding BTs in Death Stranding 2: What's Going On?
[Death Stranding 2: On The Beach] - How do BTs work in Death Stranding 2, and why do they seem to insta-kill players despite using bullets? View Answer
Can I Use Crux with Werewolf in Combat?
[The Elder Scrolls Online] - Can crux remain active in combat while transforming into a werewolf, or does the timer reset during battles? View Answer
How Do BTs Work in Death Stranding 2?
[Death Stranding 2: On The Beach] - How do BTs work in Death Stranding 2? Are they immune to bullets, and why are they causing instant voidouts? View Answer
Should I skip the first game before playing the second?
[Death Stranding] - Considering skipping the first game? Here's what players think about jumping to the second game without it. View Answer
Is My Legendary Bow Bugged?
[Fallout 76] - Is my legendary bow's last shot effect working on every arrow? Let's discuss this unusual weapon mechanic. View Answer
Problem with Preordered Game Not Showing Up on Xbox
[Sea of Thieves] - What do I do if Xbox claims I don't own a game I preordered years ago? View Answer