Should you stay in character or break character in The Silver Shroud quest?

-

In ‘The Silver Shroud’ quest, I have the option to stay in character as the Silver Shroud when confronting Sinjin or to break character. I’m not sure which choice leads to better rewards or different outcomes. What happens depending on how I approach this situation?

Should you stay in character or break character in The Silver Shroud quest
Fallout 4

Game guides, questions & answers and other Fallout 4 posts. If the answer below was not helpful, and still need Help? Submit a comment below or ask a new question.

3 Answers

Lloyd Collier -

Staying in character doesn’t really change much in terms of rewards, but it might impact Kents survival during the encounter. If you break character, you lose the opportunity for some unique dialogue but its typically easier to just go in guns blazing. No significant difference in loot or quest rewards, just makes for a different narrative.

savageeye -

staying in character as the shroud can save kent’s life if you take out enemies n talk to sinjin right breaking character doesn’t do much but give diff dialogue choices

Ray Cunningham -

If you stay in character, it can be pretty cool because you get to use the Silver Shroud’s lines, which makes the quest feel more immersive. As for Sinjin, you’ll have a chance to keep Kent alive if you deal with Sinjins henchmen quickly. I think it really adds to the role-playing aspect, but the rewards and outcomes are similar in both choices.

Leave A Reply

FALLOUT 4 QUESTIONS

How Do You Get Settlers To Watch Arena Fights?
[Fallout 4] - I need to get people in the settlement to watch an arena fight for the trophy. They aren't doing this on their own. View Answer
Please Punish Timmy Quest Bug
[Fallout 4] - I am stuck with a message telling me to punish timmy but It doesnt recognize when I do it. The quest wont stop now no matter what i do View Answer
Should I Side With Captain Ironsides or The Scavengers On The U.S.S. Constitution?
[Fallout 4] - Should I Side With Captain Ironsides or The Scavengers On The U.S.S. Constitution? It sounds like Ironsides is better but I want to know before I make the decision View Answer

RELATED QUESTIONS

What happens if you kill or spare Paladin Danse?
[Fallout 4] - In the Brotherhood quest, you find out Danse is a synth. Should you follow orders to kill him or spare him? Pros and cons of both choices. View Answer
Should I cure Virgil with the serum or keep it for myself?
[Fallout 4] - Deciding between curing Virgil or keeping the serum? Heres what happens with each choice and the possible rewards. View Answer
Return Deathclaw egg or sell it to Wellingham in Devils Due quest?
[Fallout 4] - Deciding between returning the Deathclaw egg to its nest or giving it to Wellingham in The Devils Due quest? Check the pros and cons of each. View Answer