Should I Play as Astarion Instead of My Custom Character?

-

I really enjoy Astarion for his witty dialogue and overall charm. I haven’t played Baldur’s Gate 3 since the last big updates, and I want to explore Astarion’s perspective, but I’ve mainly played as my custom Tav and Durge before. I love Durge, but I’m curious about Astarion’s story and whether it’s worth playing as him right now, especially with the new evil endings out. What do you think? Is playing Astarion a good idea, or should I save it for later?

Should I Play as Astarion Instead of My Custom Character
Baldur's Gate 3

Game guides, questions & answers and other Baldur's Gate 3 posts. If the answer below was not helpful, and still need Help? Submit a comment below or ask a new question.

6 Answers

RollingDice4Life -

If you’re into Astarion, I say go for it! You can keep your vampirism hidden until Act 1 is over, and the choices you get to make really add depth to his story. It really feels like you’re living it out from his point of view, and that can be super rewarding, especially if you love role-playing.

RomanticFool92 -

Astarion’s story really hooked me during my first playthrough. Plus, you can take risks without worrying about character approval in Act 1! It’s totally worth a shot if you love his character.

VampireHunter001 -

Honestly, I tried playing as Astarion and found it a bit underwhelming. It felt more like I was just controlling him rather than really experiencing his story. Plus, a lot of his dialogue gets replaced by the generic Tav lines, which totally takes away the charm! Some people enjoy it, but it wasn’t for me.

CuriousCat99 -

Got it, thanks! Maybe I’ll just watch some playthroughs to catch his scenes instead.

ShadowMageX -

Definitely! I’ve done a couple of runs as Astarion. Even though you miss out on his voice acting, the roleplay feels like a fresh take on the story. You’ll discover character traits and backstory bits that make the game feel unique after you’ve played Tav or Durge a bunch. Plus, being able to make choices as him can lead to hilarious or chaotic outcomes!

FanOfAstarion -

You hit the nail on the head! I remember when I first played, I was totally hooked on Astarion’s storyline. He just has a way of captivating you!

DruidLyfe -

Playing as origin characters like Astarion can be kinda bland since you miss a lot of the fun dialogue. You get a few minor cutscenes, but it really robs you of the witty banter he usually has! I think you might enjoy sticking with Durge for now unless you’re really curious about his unique endings.

AstarionFan89 -

I’ve heard that you can unlock special endings with Astarion, though. I’m torn!

EpicGamerJohn -

I think it depends on your playstyle. If you’re looking to have a more immersive experience with his character, playing Astarion could be fun! But just know that it cuts back on the richness of dialogue you’d get when you’re not him. It’s like choosing to roleplay vs a typical run—some love it, some don’t.

Leave A Reply

BALDUR'S GATE 3 QUESTIONS

Is a Life Cleric / Open Hand Monk a Good Combo for a Drow Fanatic of Ilmater?
[Baldur's Gate 3] - Is a Life Domain/Off-Hand Monk viable for a Drow fanatical cleric of Ilmater in Tactician mode? View Answer
Why Didn't Shovel Join the Party at the End?
[Baldur's Gate 3] - Why was Shovel missing from the party after defeating the elder brain? A perplexing letdown in the game. View Answer
Did I miss a lot after freeing the Nightsong at level 6-7?
[Baldur's Gate 3] - Have I missed important content in Baldur's Gate 3 after freeing Nightsong and reaching level 6-7 in 17 hours? View Answer
Can I recruit Wyll before I get Karlach?
[Baldur's Gate 3] - Can you recruit Wyll before Karlach in Baldur's Gate 3? Here's how the characters interact during gameplay. View Answer
Is There a Way to Revive the Owlbear Cub After Accidentally Killing It?
[Baldur's Gate 3] - How can I revive the Owlbear Cub I accidentally killed in Baldur's Gate 3? Seeking possible fixes. View Answer
What Should I Know Before Jumping Into Baldur's Gate 3?
[Baldur's Gate 3] - What should you know before diving into Baldur's Gate 3? Start blind for the best experience and enjoy the magic! View Answer

RELATED QUESTIONS

Can I Replace 3d6 Rolls with a d20?
[d20: Sweet Roll Club] - What is the roll ratio of 3d6 compared to d20 in gaming systems? View Answer
Looking for a Space RPG Setting for Bounty Hunters and Smugglers
What are some recommended sandbox settings for bounty hunter RPGs in a space opera theme? View Answer
Tips for My First Playthrough of Baldur's Gate
[Baldur's Gate 3] - What are the best strategies and tips for completing Act 1 of Baldur's Gate on PS5? Share your experiences! View Answer
Should I Play the Original Final Fantasy 7 Before the Remake?
[Final Fantasy VII Remake] - Should I play FF7 OG or Remake first for the best experience? Here's some advice from personal experience! View Answer
How Can I Switch to Death Domain Cleric?
[Baldur's Gate 3] - Why can't I pick Death Domain Cleric after reaching level 2 in the game? View Answer
Can I Still Romance Shadowheart After Declining Her Once?
[Baldur's Gate 3] - Can I still romance Shadowheart after rejecting her once in Baldur's Gate 3? Here's what you need to know. View Answer
How can I have Gale sacrifice himself in the finale?
[Baldur's Gate 3] - How can I ensure Gale blows himself up for the greater good at the end of Baldur's Gate 3? View Answer
What Tips Do You Wish You Knew When Starting Baldur's Gate 3?
[Baldur's Gate 3] - What insights do seasoned players wish they'd known when starting to play Baldur's Gate 3? View Answer
Advice Needed for My Commando Build at Level 178
[Fallout 76] - Seeking advice on optimal Commando build for Fallout 76 at level 178, focusing on weapons, armor, and perks. View Answer
Can I still get Minthara as a companion in Act 2?
[Baldur's Gate 3] - Can I still find Minthara as a companion in Act 2 after knocking her out in Act 1? View Answer
Which Final Fantasy Games Should I Play Next After Loving Expedition 33?
[Final Fantasy] - What modern Final Fantasy games should one play after enjoying Expedition 33's turn-based combat? View Answer
Recommendations for Story-Driven RPGs with Character Creation
Searching for a story-driven RPG focusing on character creation? Here are some top recommendations! View Answer