Help me choose the best game as a gift!

-

Hey fellow gamers! I’m looking for some advice on which video game to buy as a gift. I’ve got these four titles in mind, and I’d love to know what you all think about them:

– Elden Ring
– Horizon Forbidden West
– Ghost of Tsushima
– The Witcher 3

These games were recommended based on interests in titles like Cyberpunk, Mass Effect, Persona, Fallout: New Vegas, Dishonored, Indiana Jones, Splinter Cell, and Oblivion. If you have other suggestions outside of these, that’d be awesome too! Thanks for your help!

Help me choose the best game as a gift!
Elden Ring

Game guides, questions & answers and other Elden Ring posts. If the answer below was not helpful, and still need Help? Submit a comment below or ask a new question.

5 Answers

OpenWorldAdventurer -

Ghost of Tsushima and Elden Ring are both top-tier picks. But keep in mind that Elden Ring can be pretty tough, which might not be ideal for someone who’s not very experienced with games. Also, make sure the recipient has played the first Horizon game if you’re considering Forbidden West.

QuestMaster5000 -

All these games are fantastic, but it really depends on what kind of game the recipient enjoys. If I had to recommend:
1. Elden Ring – if they’re ready for a challenge and epic gameplay.
2. Ghost of Tsushima – super immersive and a great story.
3. The Witcher 3 – an all-time classic.
4. Horizon Forbidden West – it’s great, but they’d need to have played the first game for the full experience.

GameGuru77 -

Witcher 3 has a rich story and great characters, but some people find the quests a bit lacking in satisfying outcomes. I’ve tried to finish it but ended up getting bored. On the other hand, the gameplay and atmosphere are top-notch!

SciFiFanatic88 -

It sounds like the person you’re gifting has a love for sci-fi, so I’d steer them toward something like Space Marine 2. While the other games are great, they don’t really fit that genre. If forced to choose from this list, Horizon Forbidden West could work since it has a futuristic setting, even if it’s more medieval.

StealthNinja99 -

Elden Ring is amazing! Once the gameplay clicks, it has tons of replay value. Ghost of Tsushima is also a standout; it’s one of the best single-player experiences I’ve had, and I seriously wish I could experience it fresh again. Could also go for The Witcher 3 for great value hours per dollar, but just be aware it might get a bit slow for some.

Leave A Reply

ELDEN RING QUESTIONS

Do Xbox Digital Codes Make Games Free?
[Elden Ring] - Do Xbox digital codes truly make games like Elden Ring free or is there a cost involved? View Answer
What are some great co-op adventure games for multiple players?
[Elden Ring] - What are the best co-op adventure games for multiplayer quests and customization similar to Dragons Dogma 2? View Answer
Looking for Awesome Non-Multiplayer Games to Dive Into
[Elden Ring] - What are the best single-player games worth exploring beyond multiplayer options and FPS titles? View Answer
My Games Are Lagging After a Driver Update—What Can I Do?
[Elden Ring] - Why are my games running at 15 fps despite having an updated graphics driver? Here's what could be going on. View Answer
Why Can't I Play PS5 Games from My External Drive Anymore?
[Elden Ring] - Is there a new update preventing PS5 games from running on external drives? This seems unfair to gamers. View Answer
Looking for Game Recommendations After Building My First PC
[Elden Ring] - Looking for game recommendations for my new PC, focusing on story-driven games and options to play with friends. View Answer

RELATED QUESTIONS

Can I play my disk copy of Elden Ring on PS5 without a disk drive?
[Elden Ring] - How can I play my PS4 disk version of Elden Ring on a PS5 without a disk drive? View Answer
Looking for Resident Evil Gift Ideas for My Girlfriend
[Resident Evil] - Looking for Christmas gift ideas for a Resident Evil fan? Check out these fun and thoughtful suggestions! View Answer
Can I Transfer My Horizon Forbidden West Save from PS4 to PS5 for Burning Shores DLC?
[Horizon Forbidden West] - Can I transfer my Horizon Forbidden West save from PS4 to PS5 for the Burning Shores DLC without replaying the main game? View Answer
Will Elden Ring be available on the PC Xbox App?
[Elden Ring] - Will Elden Ring be available on the PC Xbox App? Currently, it's not listed. View Answer
Help Me Choose: Elden Ring or Dune: Awakening for My Steam Deck?
[Dune: Awakening] - Deciding between Elden Ring and Dune: Awakening while waiting for my Steam Deck repair. What's your pick? View Answer
What are some fun Pokémon gift ideas for a 4-year-old?
[Pokémon] - Looking for gift ideas for a 4-year-old Pokémon fan? Here are some great age-appropriate suggestions. View Answer
What TTRPGs Fit a Non-Magic, Human-Only Campaign?
[DND] - What are some TTRPG suggestions for a campaign focused on humans without magic, like Ghost of Tsushima? View Answer
Is Elden Ring Worth Playing on the Steam Deck?
[Elden Ring] - How does Elden Ring perform on Steam Deck compared to PS5? Looking for player experiences and graphics quality. View Answer
Why Does My Game Connection Keep Dropping?
Experiencing random connection interruptions while gaming? Seeking advice on fixes for signal errors. View Answer
Help! I Overwrote My Elden Ring Save File – Any Recovery Tips?
[Elden Ring] - Accidentally overwrote my Elden Ring save file. How can I recover 200 hours of gameplay? View Answer
Accidentally Overwrote My Elden Ring Save File—Is There Any Way to Recover It?
[Elden Ring] - Help! I accidentally overwrote my Elden Ring save file and need recovery tips to retrieve 200 hours of gameplay. View Answer
Is Elden Ring Worth Playing on Steam Deck?
[Elden Ring] - Wondering if Elden Ring runs well on Steam Deck? Discover user experiences and performance insights here! View Answer